Monday, March 29, 2010

_Utena_-Based Theodicy

I had an interesting theodicy idea but don't really have time to write about it. But it's definitely interesting. The idea, which stems from an online conversation with a friend, touching on theodicy, in which the friend asked some of her Christian friends to explain Jesus for us, is basically to assume that the situation of the universe is more or less the situation of Ohotori Academy in Utena (which is, I think, an intended interpretation of Utena, which is an explicitly Gnostic work, although I think there's also a lot of Buddhist influence that is more beyond me), but then to start from a more Christian viewpoint of God as prior to time, which means that the situation that leads to the complete messing up of Dios and his sister in Utena is in fact the fault of the complete messed-up-ness of Dios and his sister. Or, in more Christian terms, the reason why Jesus has to redeem mankind for its sins is because mankind sins, but the reason why mankind sins in the first place is because Jesus/God is timelessly messed up from the act of having died and gone to Hell. This sounds too circular to be interesting, but I think it is nonetheless interesting, as long as you accept the idea of God as unmoved mover. Thus, if God is flawed, God must be flawed because of its own action: this is only logical. It's not a theodicy that justifies Christianity or leaves us with an omnipotent, omnipresent, and omniscient God. But it is a fun variety of Gnosticism, I think. I wish it would work to make me appreciate Utena more viscerally (I tend to appreciate it intellectually but never find that it quite works for me on an emotional level), but I definitely like the idea that the real God might have things in common with Akio and Anthy, because they're much more interesting characters than Jesus as I know him.

3 comments:

靜宜靜宜 said...

qvod色情影片色情qvod色情視訊電話色情美眉寫真色情片免華人最大男同志聊天室貼片下載無碼影片直播無碼影片一無碼電影18無碼片試看無碼片網無碼成人片免費看無碼成人免費片無碼色網無碼免費直播無碼免費試看無碼動畫下載無碼動畫影片無碼專業網無碼愛愛無碼電話無碼電話下載貼片免費看貼色影片黑絲貼圖黑絲影片黑襪片黑襪影片亂倫動漫金瓶梅影片 自拍俱樂部 尋夢園聊天聯盟pc交友

jj said...

Of course I don't understand almost all the references to literature!

BJ said...

literally wonder filled thoughts. thought provoking, exciting. hmmm. if my life ins a story... wonder how interesting it is, clearly sometimes better to be boring. Also, when people believe(d) in Gods in control of various elements- they certainly weren't necessarily good or moral Gods. I guess that definition has changed somewhat...